DemDaily: Supreme Court Contemplates Birthright Citizenship

April 8, 2026

Last Wednesday, April 1, the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) heard oral arguments in a case debating the 158-year-old clause to the US Constitution under the 14th Amendment, which guarantees Birthright Citizenship for all children born in our country -- regardless of their parents' immigration status.

It is the latest assault by the Trump Administration on the Constitution and the legal and civil rights of Americans.

"Barbara v. Trump," a class-action lawsuit brought by the ACLU and some two dozen states, challenges Executive Order 14160, signed by President Donald Trump on his first day in office, January 21, 2025, seeking to deny US citizenship to children born in the US if neither parent is a citizen or lawful permanent resident. Although lower federal courts blocked the order as "blatantly unconstitutional," SCOTUS agreed to hear the case at the request of the Trump Administration.

History
The birthright Citizenship Clause has been enshrined as the law of the land since 1868, when the Constitution was ratified following the Civil War -- to overturn the 1857 Dred Scott decision, which had ruled that Black people could not be citizens.

The modern understanding of the amendment was further solidified in 1898, in United States v. Wong Kim Ark, the landmark Supreme Court case which ruled that a man born in San Francisco to Chinese immigrant parents was a US citizen. This established the precedent that birthright citizenship applies to the children of immigrants, even those ineligible for naturalization.

In 1924, under the Indian Citizenship Act, birthright citizenship was extended to Native Americans, who had previously been excluded because they were considered members of sovereign tribes rather than "subject to the jurisdiction" of the US.

In January 2020, immediately following Trump's first inauguration, his administration announced that the State Department “will no longer issue temporary visitor (B-1/B-2) visas to aliens seeking to enter the United States for "birth tourism." The term, used by supporters of immigration restrictions, refers to foreign nationals whose “primary purpose” for travel is to give birth on US soil to ensure their children become American citizens.

Issued the first day of his second term, Trump's January 2025 Executive Order, titled “Protecting the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship,” directed an end to birthright citizenship -- to be enforced by withholding documents such as passports and state and local government legal status identification from people it deems ineligible for citizenship. The administration has yet to clarify what authority would make those decisions.

Trump has falsely claimed the US is the only country that offers birthright citizenship when, in fact, more than 30 countries offer jus soli (right of soil) citizenship, including Canada, Mexico, and most of South America.

“The great promise of our nation is that everyone born here is a citizen of the United States, able to achieve the American dream. This fundamental right to birthright citizenship, rooted in the 14th Amendment and born from the ashes of slavery, is a cornerstone of our nation’s commitment to justice."... President Trump’s unlawful action "is not just unconstitutional, it is profoundly dangerous." - New York Attorney General Letitia James, co-plaintiff, State of Massachusetts v. Trump, 1/21/26

The Case
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and 22 states challenged the order in court as violating the Fourteenth Amendment of the US Constitution.

Between January 23 and February 13, US District Judges in Seattle, Maryland, New Hampshire, and Massachusetts, citing the order as "blatantly unconstitutional," issued preliminary injunctions to block its going into effect. In May, the Supreme Court agreed to hear the Trump administration's challenge, which argued that lower court judges should not be able to block nationwide policies.

In June 2025, in Trump v. CASA, the high court ruled that the lower courts could not use injunctions to block the implementation of the orders nationwide as long as court cases regarding the constitutionality of the orders remained ongoing. Federal courts could, however, give relief to plaintiffs with standing to sue.

The ACLU and the states immediately filed a motion to certify a class of born and unborn children of immigrant parents who would be ineligible for birthright citizenship under the order, and in July, federal Judge Laplante (NH) granted the class action status, issuing a preliminary injunction blocking the order from being enforced upon that class.

In September 2025, the Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to hear its appeal, and in December 2025, SCOTUS granted certiorari, agreeing to hear oral arguments in the Spring on the constitutionality of the president's birthright citizen order.

On April 1, 2026, Trump became the first sitting president in US history to attend oral arguments at the Supreme Court. Legal experts characterized the visit as an attempt to openly intimidate the justices, three of whom he appointed.

The president, who was accompanied by US Attorney General Pam Bondi and White House Counsel David Warrington, stayed 80 minutes before abruptly walking out after the ACLU's opposing argument commenced. Reports speculated that a majority of the justices, including some of the conservatives, appeared skeptical of the administration's legal arguments.

An April 2, 2026, YouGov poll of US adults found that 55% believe all children born in the United States should automatically become citizens, while 35% believe this right should only apply if parents are citizens or lawful residents.

The court is expected to hand down its decision in late June or July 2026 when the justices announce major decisions at the close of the term this Summer.

DemList will keep you informed.

DemList
Connecting You to The Party
Connecting You to Each Other

Kimberly Scott
Publisher

Please Support Our Work!

SignUp for the Daily updates on policy, politics and the players.
Follow DemList on Bluesky, Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn

Sources: Brennan Center, New York Times, Washington Post, Reuters, Huff Post, White House, The Hill, SCOTUS Blog, CNN, ACLU, YouGov

Related posts

DemDaily: The COVID Count

DemDaily: The COVID Count

January 12, 2022 We are now two years into the devastating coronavirus pandemic that has claimed the lives of more than 840,000 Americans. Just as Americans were welcoming signs of a return to...