DemDaily: Abuse of Power. Trial Day Three

January 24, 2020

In another marathon session, House Impeachment Managers on Thursday laid out their arguments for the first Article of Impeachment in the third day of the impeachment trial of President Donald J. Trump.

Under the organizing resolution approved Tuesday along party lines, each side has up to 24 hours, spread over three days, to argue their case -- starting with the House Managers, led by House Intelligence Committee Chair Adam Schiff (D-CA). Further debate and votes on whether to call witnesses are postponed until after the completion of presentations.

Day Three
After walking through the facts of the case on Wednesday, House Managers outlined the specific evidence against Trump for Abuse of Power on Thursday.

House Manager & Congresswoman Sylvia Garcia (D-TX)  (Senate TV)

"The articles and the evidence conclusively establish that President Trump has placed his own personal, political interests first. This conduct is not America first, it is Donald Trump first." -- Jerry Nadler (D-NY)

Although the arguments, in part, rehashed previous evidence, the emphasis was on proving the constitutional violations and, as Schiff stated, to "apply the facts to the law as it pertains to the president's abuse of power."

The Managers also focused more extensively on Trump's ultimate goal of taking down his political opponent, former Vice President Joe Biden, while underscoring the fact that Biden and his son, Hunter, had been cleared of any wrongdoing.

"President Trump wanted to hurt Vice President Biden's candidacy and help himself politically." -- Sylvia Garcia

Detractors, however, say that including the Bidens in the debate also increases chances of Republicans insisting on their testimony as witnesses, providing an opportunity to scrutinize their actions on the stand.

Hunter and Joe Biden. Potential witnesses? (Visar Kryeziu/AP)

The role of the President's personal attorney, Rudy Giuliani, also played a more prominent role in yesterday's hearings.

The Managers used multiple exhibits, including video of Giuliani's own words, to prove his part as the architect and executioner of the President's scheme to withhold military assistance from Ukraine in exchange for a publicly-announced investigation of the Bidens by President Zelensky.

Hakeem Jefferies (D-NY), after playing the video of Ambassador Gordon Sondland's testimony confirming the "quid-pro-quo," said, "Did President Trump abuse his power and conduct an impeachable offense? The answer is yes."

Jeffries went on,"President Trump sought to advance his own personal interests, facilitated by Rudolph Giuliani, the 'human hand-grenade.'" -- referring to Ambassador John Bolton's name for Giuliani.

Other parts of the presentation were clearly aimed at preempting the arguments by Trump's legal team, including that of legal scholar Alan Dershowitz, which start Saturday.

Sondland: "Was there a quid-pro-quo? The answer is yes."

Nadler played a 1988 video of Dershowitz's comments on the Clinton Impeachment, in which he said, "If you have somebody who completely corrupts the office of president, and who abuses trust, and who poses great danger to our liberty, you don't need a technical crime." In contrast, Dershowitz is now arguing that Trump can't be removed from office for abuse of power because that's not a federal crime.

Nadler also pointed to a June, 2018 memo by now-Trump US Attorney General and key defender, William Barr, written prior to his appointment. "The fact that the President is answerable for any abuses of discretion and is ultimately subject to the judgement of Congress through the impeachment process means that the President is not the judge in his own cause. The remedy of impeachment demonstrates that the President remains accountable under law for his misdeeds in office."

In yet another condemning contradiction, Nadler showed video of Senator Lindsay Graham (R-SC), one of Trump's most vociferous defenders, speaking to impeachable offenses during Clinton's trial twenty years ago.

"What's a high crime? How about an important person hurts somebody of low means? It's not very scholarly, but I think it's the truth." -- Senator Lindsay Graham, 1999

Schiff effectively detailed every point (WashPost)

Lead Manager Adam Schiff masterfully walked through the details of ten points of evidence that Trump was motivated by his own personal gains.

"He was doing it because it helped him. For that he would sacrifice our ally and our own security." -- Adam Schiff

Next Up
The trial continues today, Friday, January 24th at 1:00pm ET. Democrats, who have close to eight hours remaining in their presentation, are expected to focus on Impeachment Article Two, Obstruction of Congress.

President Trump's legal team will begin their defense Saturday at 10:00pm.

DemList will keep you informed.


DemDaily: In Defense of the Constitution. The Impeachment of Donald J. Trump 12/18/19

Connecting you to The Party
Connecting you to Each Other

Kimberly Scott

Support DemList!

Support DemList!

Sign Up for the Daily updates on the issues, politics and the players

Follow DemList on FacebookTwitter and LinkedIn


Sources: New York Times, Washington Post, Slate, C-Span

Related posts

DemDaily: The Impeachment Rollout

DemDaily: The Impeachment Rollout

November 1, 2019 On Thursday, October 31, 2019, the US House of Representatives formally voted to move forward with impeachment proceedings against President Donald Trump. The 232 to 196 vote...